Before I start into an incensed rant, I will openly admit that what I am about to write is pathetic and sad. Pathetic because I care enough to be upset about a ridiculous TV show and sad because I put effort into blogging about it. Unfortunately, I cannot help it. For the past seven years I have devotedly watched American Idol. Some seasons have been hit and miss (4 and 5) - work or school would get in the way, but now my schedule is open at night and I have been able to indulge in one of my guilty pleasures. Yet, judging from my reaction to tonight's show I think that I need to find a new hobby to lower my blood pressure and save my sanity.
At a glance tonight's show seemed like a perfect opportunity for Idol to gain some credibility. Finally a new theme: "Rock n' Roll" night. Fresh songs, Slash as a mentor (yes, SLASH), no cheesy ballads, studded leather; what's not to love? The show opened, Adam performed Zepplin and I thought to myself, self, this could be a good night. Then Adam finished and naturally the panel (I don't think "judges" is applicable to those four, do you?) fell all over themselves with compliments. Sure, Adam was great. Big deal. Anyone who has followed the show knows that he has been the destined winner since the beginning. My interest was more piqued when Allison Iraheta (with her fuchsia hair, raspy voice, cannot-believe-she-is-only-sixteen talent) performed. Yes, her Cry Baby was a bit more Joplin than Iraheta, but she still proved that she not only has pipes, but that she can wail and really rock. But did she get the praise and mad props she deserved? Of course not - because the panel still had visions of Adam dancing in their heads and only gave her lukewarm compliments.
Which leads me to the heart of my rant. The crux of my problem, the conspiracy that has been eating at me all season long. Kris Allen and Danny Gokey covered Styx's Renegade after Allison's performance. Was their duet a bit "pitchy" (get a Thesaurus, Randy)? Yes, but surely Danny's 60 seconds of the song were not that much better to be called out over Kris'. And even if he was better than Kris in Renegade was his screeching, insufferable Dream On really worth praising? Sure, his beginning had promise, the middle was fairing - but did we all hear the same ending - as in the high-pitched screechy final note that only Wolverine could hear properly?! It is a good thing that Steven Tyler was the mentor this week because he would have covered his ears in utter shock and gone into an ET-like (you know the part I'm talking about, where they take of picture of E.T. and he starts screaming - kind of like that) rage at his seminal song being defaced.
To make matters worse, my mouth was wide open in disgust when I heard the panel tell Danny that his performance was good enough to keep him in the competition. Keep him? This guy should have been given the axe weeks ago, that is if the American public would wake up and smell the FM100. The story about his wife was sad, yes, but is that any reason to keep voting for him? Honestly, if there are any Danny Gokey fans out there will you really buy a record from this guy? Really?! Do you truly in your heart of hearts think that he has a fighting chance on the charts? Keep in mind that despite his song choices he is not competing in 1990 against the Michael Boltons, Boyz to Mens, and Christopher McDonalds of the world; no we are talking about Justin Timberlake, Cold Play, and a slew of hard core musicians with crazy names like GaGa, NeYo and Flo-rida. Not only is this man not current he is smug and just plain unlikable. After each performance he smiles his little smile, flashes his finger sign to the crowd, and doesn't even listen to the panels' critiques. Which makes me wonder, if this Robert Downey Jr. look-alike already knows everything, why is he even competing, because judging by his body language and lack of ingenuity, he is above reproach.
So why, Idol producers do you keep this chump in the competition? Why do you insist that each and every show one (and on occasion two or more) of the panel tell Gokey that they will "see him in the finals?" Why do you insult our intelligence and worst of all, why do you slight the talents of Allison and Kris? Because the jig is up. We have already figured out from the beginning that you pick and choose the people that you want in the competition - and unfortunately your television audience typically votes like you tell them to and cannot be relied on for their own opinions.
Pity.
I better not quit my day job.
3 comments:
You made me laugh, sorry I don't think this was the reaction you were looking for. You have always been passionate from your rock collecting, loving your ferret Newman when no one else did, your love for the Beatles, your drama performances, and now your love for art. Seriously, Midgie you are a hoot. But then again I am almost as passionate with the Jazz as you are Idol. Blood pressure medication is a good thing, want some?
Oh Midge. I have it taped, but I haven't watched it quite yet. Now I am more excited to, and see what all the fuss is about! I totally agree with you though, from the past shows that Alison and Kris should be kept over Danny. Hopefully all the voters will think the same, eh?
Hilarious.
This is the first season JT & I have watched, but we are hooked.
So who are you voting for?!
Post a Comment