Monday, January 21, 2008

A "historical" hoax...

Last week the "History" Channel was promoting a special program about "Life after People." I saw several commercials for it on cable, and I heard it advertised on the radio at least once a day. Then I saw an extended trailer for this program while I was at the movies on Saturday. It showed the filmmakers in Chernobyl, Ukraine using images of the ghostly city to simulate footage of a "human-less" world. The filmmakers explained that the city's "traumatized" characteristics made it an ideal location for their film and that it showed the "eeriness" of a world void of man. Empty streets, abandoned buildings, streets overrun with plant-life, and a rusty merry-go-round reiterated this loneliness, and I am sure the filmmakers used these images to "haunt" their viewers. However, after seeing this trailer I couldn't help but think of two questions:
1. Are these people going to be sued by the makers of "I am Legend?"

and

2. How can this be on the "History" channel when it hasn't even happened yet?!

Now, let me just say that while my rant is not wholly accurate, it is nonetheless justified. I do not claim to be a historian, but I would like to think I have an educated opinion. So when I first learned that there was a channel entirely devoted to history, I marveled. To think, there would finally be a place that was history-buff friendly. Yet to my disappointment the "History" channel has been on the decline for years...probably since its inception. As a station that relies heavily on reenactments rather than historical documents the channel has little credibility in my book.

Take a "History" channel documentary about George Washington for example. There is no doubt that the man is a great figure in American history. And as such, he had hundreds (and I am not exaggerating) of portraits, quilts, murals, and other such arts dedicated to him. But you do not see these material objects on "History" channel documentaries. Instead, what you do see is a "movie" starring a man that slightly resembles George Washington who rides around on a horse and fires a musket in the air. When did feature films replace history? Do the corporate-suits behind the "History" channel really believe that the American public will be duped by a look-alike instead of evidence?!

And that leads me back to my original argument about "Life after People." Since when did a channel devoted to history run out of actual historical events and/or persons? It seems to me that the "History" channel has hit a brick wall in their programming. They have showed so many sub-par programs about WWII machinery and the invention of Blow Pops and Dr. Pepper (these are actual programs) that they feel they have run out. Of course history is rooted to the past just as much as it is rooted in the present and even the future. But I find it ironic that they just didn't make a documentary about Chernobyl and the actual horrors that took place there instead of making a sci-fi knockoff and calling it "history"... Until the entire history of man has been documented, the good, the bad, and the ugly, there is no room for conjecture or entertaining estimations.

PS- I changed the settings on my blog so ANYONE can comment, not just gmail users. So please drop me a line!

3 comments:

The Mama said...

I admit that I am not a frequent history channel watcher, but your post sure made me laugh!! I totally agree with you!!

athomson said...

midgie, you never cease to amaze me with your wealth of knowledge and opinions! you go girl!!!
mutti

Be You Movies said...

Oh, Erin! How you make me chuckle! I love your opinions and you are so knowledgable. I had no idea that the history channel was so sub par! Maybe that is why I haven't been watching it. . . nope, that probably isn't it. I am a style addict! Love ya!